Independent publication

Latest filing

Story file

Should I pay off my car loan early? Check the method first

Paying a car loan off early saves interest on a simple-interest loan. On a precomputed one it depends on the refund method. A worked example shows the gap.

By Staff, Repay Desk News Auto Loans Early Settlement Arithmetic 1,110 words 6 min read

Should I pay off my car loan early? On a simple-interest loan, paying early saves all the interest not yet charged, less any prepayment fee your contract names. On a precomputed loan, the interest was fixed at signing, so the saving is whatever share of it the lender must refund, and the refund method decides how much that is.

This is an evergreen explainer, not news. This desk read the US Code text of 15 U.S.C. 1615 and the Regulation Z disclosure rule in 12 CFR 1026.18 on 1 November 2026. Both are US federal law; other countries set their own rules.

Should I pay off my car loan early? First, which kind of loan is it?

On a simple-interest loan, interest is charged on the balance as it stands. Every dollar of principal paid early stops interest on that dollar from then on.

On a precomputed loan, the finance charge for the whole term is worked out at the start and added to what you owe. Paying early does not stop interest accruing, because none accrues: it was all charged at signing. What you get back is a rebate of the unearned part.

Your Truth in Lending disclosure tells you which you hold. Under section 1026.18(k), a loan whose charge is computed by applying a rate to the unpaid principal must state whether a charge may be imposed for paying early. Any other finance charge must come with a statement of whether you are entitled to a rebate if you prepay. As the rule is drafted, a penalty statement goes with simple interest and a rebate statement with a precomputed charge. Section 1026.18(p) also tells you to look in the contract for prepayment rebates and penalties. Our post on paying off a personal loan early explains why a blank on that line does not mean there is no penalty.

Does paying off a car loan early save interest? A worked example

Illustrative desk arithmetic, not any lender’s offer. It assumes a $20,000 loan at 7% APR, on-time monthly payments, and payoff on a due date with no per diem adjustment. Over 60 months the payment is $396.02 and the total finance charge is $3,761.20; over 72 months, $340.98 and $4,550.56.

The actuarial column is the interest a simple-interest loan avoids, and the refund a precomputed loan gives under the method 15 U.S.C. 1615(d) defines: each payment goes first to interest accrued, the rest to the balance. The Rule of 78s column is the sum-of-the-digits method the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions explains on its consumer pages.

Loan, payments madeBalance to pay off (actuarial)Interest saved or refunded, actuarialRefunded under Rule of 78sYou lose under 78s
60 months, after 12$16,538.09$2,470.87$2,417.03$53.84
60 months, after 24$12,825.92$1,430.80$1,368.83$61.97
60 months, after 36$8,845.39$659.09$616.59$42.50
72 months, after 12$17,220.18$3,238.62$3,168.77$69.85
72 months, after 24$14,239.40$2,127.64$2,036.32$91.31
72 months, after 36$11,043.15$1,232.13$1,153.22$78.91

Two things stand out. The saving shrinks fast: interest is front-loaded, so after 36 of 60 payments only $659.09 is left to save. And the Rule of 78s shifts more interest into the early months, so a borrower who pays off early gets less back than the actuarial figure.

When is the Rule of 78s banned on a car loan?

Federal law bans it only in part. Section 1615(b) says that for a precomputed consumer credit transaction with a term exceeding 61 months, consummated after 30 September 1993, the refund must use a method at least as favourable to the consumer as the actuarial method. In the table, the 72-month Rule of 78s figures show what that rule forbids.

A 60-month precomputed loan is outside that federal ban. State law may still restrict the method, but this desk has not checked any state’s rules, so check your own state’s consumer credit rules before assuming either way.

Whatever the method, section 1615(a) requires the lender to refund the unearned part of the interest when any consumer credit transaction is paid off in full, unless the refund is under $1. That applies whatever the reason for paying off, including a refinance or consolidation.

How do you get the payoff figure?

Ask for it in writing. On a precomputed account, section 1615(c) says the lender must state the amount needed to pay in full, and any refund included in it, within five days of an oral or written request. Our post on how long a lender has to send a payoff statement covers the timing for other loans, and per diem interest explains why a simple-interest payoff grows between due dates. After the money arrives, the title is the next document to wait for.

Common questions

Can you pay off a car loan early?

In the US, generally yes, but whether it costs anything is set by your contract. The Truth in Lending disclosure must say whether a prepayment charge may apply, or, on a precomputed loan, whether you are entitled to a rebate of the finance charge. Read that line before you ask for a payoff figure, and ask the lender to point to it if you cannot find it.

What happens if you pay off your car loan early?

You pay the payoff amount and the account closes. On a simple-interest loan, interest that has not yet accrued is never charged. On a precomputed loan, federal law requires the lender to refund the unearned part of the interest, unless the refund would be under $1. The lender then releases its lien so the title can pass to you.

Is it worth paying off a car loan early or just let it ride until the end?

That depends on what the payoff saves and what the money would do instead. Work out the interest still to come, or the rebate due, and subtract any prepayment charge. Then set that figure against keeping an emergency reserve or paying down debt at a higher rate. A small saving late in the loan may not justify emptying savings.

Nothing here is financial advice. Your loan agreement and its disclosure set the real figures for your car loan. If the prepayment line is unclear, ask the lender in writing what it means before you send the money, and read any new credit agreement in full before you sign.

All stories