Independent publication

Latest filing

Story file

What is good debt? The label against published rates

Good debt costs little next to what it buys and is repaid on schedule. Nine published US rates show the label follows cost, not the type of loan.

By Staff, Repay Desk Credit Cards Personal Loans Mortgages Student Loans 1,314 words 7 min read

Good debt is borrowing whose interest cost is low next to what it pays for, and which you can repay on the agreed schedule. Mortgages and student loans are the usual examples. The label describes cost and repayment, not a loan type: priced at published rates, a “good” loan can cost more than a car loan.

This is an evergreen explainer; the rates in it are dated and will move, the method will not. On 13 November 2026 this desk read the Federal Reserve’s G.19 Consumer Credit release dated November 6, 2026, Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey for the week to November 12, 2026, and Federal Student Aid’s announcement of 2026-27 Direct Loan rates. US figures only.

What is good debt, priced category by category?

The last column is the rate times $1,000: what a balance of $1,000 held for a full year costs in interest, simple, before any repayment. It is this desk’s arithmetic, not a figure in any source.

CategorySource and periodPublished rateInterest a year per $1,000Usual label
Credit card plans, accounts assessed interestG.19, Q3 2026 (preliminary)22.36%$223.60Bad
Credit card plans, all accountsG.19, Q3 2026 (preliminary)21.19%$211.90Bad
Personal loan, 24-month, commercial bankG.19, Q3 2026 (preliminary)11.90%$119.00Depends on use
Direct Unsubsidized, graduate and professionalFSA, first disbursed July 1, 2026 to June 30, 20278.07%$80.70Good
New car loan, 60-month, commercial bankG.19, Q3 2026 (preliminary)7.54%$75.40Mixed
New car loan, 72-month, commercial bankG.19, Q3 2026 (preliminary)7.17%$71.70Mixed
30-year fixed mortgageFreddie Mac PMMS, week to November 12, 20267.11%$71.10Good
Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized, undergraduateFSA, same period6.52%$65.20Good
15-year fixed mortgageFreddie Mac PMMS, week to November 12, 20266.45%$64.50Good

The “usual label” column is the shorthand good-versus-bad explainers apply by type; it is not a judgment from any of the three sources.

The three sources measure different things, so the rows are comparable only roughly. G.19 states its rates are APRs as specified by the Federal Reserve’s Regulation Z. Its car and personal-loan figures are simple averages of each bank’s most common rate in the first week of the quarter’s middle month. “All accounts” averages the stated APR on every card account; “accounts assessed interest” divides finance charges by the balances they were charged on. PMMS rates come from applications submitted to Freddie Mac through Loan Product Advisor. Direct Loan rates are set by formula and, in FSA’s words, fixed “for the life of that loan”.

Does the good-debt label follow the category or the cost?

The cost. Read down the table and the types do not sort cleanly. The graduate Direct Unsubsidized rate, 8.07%, sits above both new-car averages, a category often filed as bad because the car loses value. The 30-year mortgage average, 7.11%, sits within half a point of the 60-month car loan.

The one clear break is credit cards. At about 21% to 22%, a card balance costs roughly three times a car loan or a mortgage per $1,000, and nearly twice the 24-month personal loan. That gap, not the good/bad vocabulary, is the useful part of the label.

The second half of the definition is repayment. A cheap loan you cannot keep up with turns bad through late fees, default and damage to your record, whatever it financed.

Is a mortgage or a student loan always good debt?

No. Both are called good because they can finance a home or an income. But the 30-year average this desk read was 7.11%, and a federal graduate loan first disbursed in the 2026-27 year carries 8.07% for its life. Neither is cheap in absolute terms.

The FSA announcement also sets statutory maximums: 8.25% for undergraduate Direct Loans, 9.50% for graduate Direct Unsubsidized and 10.50% for PLUS. A loan from a different award year can carry a different fixed rate, so the rate on your own loan is the one that counts.

Is a car loan good debt?

It is usually called mixed. A car can be needed to earn an income, but it is not expected to hold its value. On price, the bank averages read here, 7.17% at 72 months and 7.54% at 60 months, sit beside the 30-year mortgage, not beside cards. Whether yours is “good” is the same two questions: what does it cost, and can you pay it on time. Our piece on whether to pay off a car loan early runs that test on one loan.

What does a 6% rule of thumb miss?

A common shorthand calls debt under about 6% good. Every published average in the table is above it, the 15-year mortgage included at 6.45%. Taken literally, the rule would call no category good on these figures.

It also misses that averages are not your rate. A borrower with a 3% mortgage from an earlier year and a card at 22% carries one balance under the line and one far above it. The rate that matters is the APR on your own Truth in Lending disclosure or card statement. For how a card payment above the minimum is applied, see where a payment above the card minimum goes.

Which of your balances costs most per $1,000?

For a reader already carrying debt, the label matters less than the order. Multiply each balance’s APR by $1,000 and rank them. The top of that list is where extra money removes the most interest; the bottom is the debt that is cheap to hold.

Two cautions. The per-$1,000 figure is simple and annual: an instalment loan’s balance falls with each payment, so the interest actually paid is lower. And moving a balance from one category to another changes the fees as well as the rate; our debt consolidation assessment shows that arithmetic. Why these totals are measured differently is covered in what consumer debt is.

Frequently asked questions

What is good debt?

Good debt is borrowing whose interest cost is low next to what it pays for, and which you can repay on the agreed schedule. Mortgages and student loans are the usual examples because they finance an asset or an income. The label describes a cost and a repayment record, not a loan type, so a mortgage can be expensive and still be called good.

Good debt vs. bad debt: what’s the difference?

The usual line is that good debt finances something that holds or builds value at a modest rate, and bad debt finances spending at a high rate. The published rates put credit card plans near 21% to 22% APR and the other categories in this desk’s table between 6.45% and 11.90%. The bigger split is between card balances and everything else, not between good and bad types.

What is good and bad debt, explained simply?

Debt is renting money. Good debt is cheap rent on money that buys something lasting, paid on time. Bad debt is expensive rent on money that is already spent, or any debt you cannot keep up with. At the card rate this desk read, $1,000 held for a year costs about $212 to $224 in interest; at the 15-year mortgage average, about $65.

The rates above are published averages read on one date, set out so a reader can compare their own balances; they are not an offer, a forecast or advice on whether to borrow. Your own agreement and statement carry the rate that applies to you.

All stories